Translate / Traducir

Mexican coins used in Canada

Newfoundland

Long before it became a Canadian province in 1949, Newfoundland operated with its own sovereign currency system, initially utilizing the Newfoundland Pound before switching to its own independent, gold-standard decimal Newfoundland Dollar in 1865. Early military and merchant trade heavily relied on token economies, using items such as the Ordnance Dollars.

Heralded in 1905 as an important numismatic discovery and later demonized as an utter fraud, these Spanish American dollars countermarked GR 5 ORD have known a chequered past. Paul Berry's "The Ordnance Dollars of Newfoundland" by Christopher Faulkner, David Bergeron, Paul Berry, and Markus Molenda, Newfoundland Numismatics: A Collection of Essays identifies the parties responsible for their production, proposes where and when they were distributed, and reveals the dollars' surprising connection to Britain's oldest colony in Canada. It catalogues known examples in their many varieties and using numismatic and non-numismatic references, collection databases, and digital sales records traces their appearance over the last hundred plus years among some of the hobby's most prominent dealers and collectors.

Prince Edward Island
(Stephen Album Rare Coins, Auction 53, 18 September 2025. lot 992)

"GR / 5 / ORD" countermark on an 8r 1770 Mo MF (KM-105). The GR stands for Georgius Rex (King George III of Great Britain); 5 represents the value it was assigned, viz. 5 Shillings, and ORD refers to Ordnance.

Prince Edward Island

Around the end of the 18th century, the Spanish dollar was in constant circulation in Eastern Canada and the United States. The value of the coin varied in different centres but was highest in Halifax. Therefore, whenever the merchants of Prince Edward Island secured them, they sent them to Halifax to take advantage of the higher rate. The resulting shortage of money in Prince Edward Island prompted lieutenant governor Charles Douglass Smith, on 24 September 1813{/Weekly Recorder, 25 November 1813footnote} to gather in all the Spanish dollars he could and have their centres punched out, whereupon the central plug and rims were stamped with a sunburst. The punched centres passed as shillings and the outer rims as five-shilling pieces. The combined value of the mutilated coins was thereafter 20 per cent greater in Prince Edward Island than outside the island (and the individual components less valuable), so as a consequence, the coins became the official currency in Prince Edward Island.

Christopher Faulkner in his outstanding surveyChristoher Faulkner, The Holey Dollars and Dumps of Prince Edward Island, Spink, distinguished thirteen different groups of Holey Dollars and Dumps, the first six based on differences in the countermark.

Group A (Twelve Rays)

This countermark is quite crude and is comprised of twelve points or rays of uneven size. All coins were pierced using the hard punch method. They were all pierced from the obverse and the hole produced is somewhat irregular in shape.

PEI Capital City dollarPEI Capital City dollar reversePEI Capital City dollar detail
“Capital City Dollar”, an 8r 1792 Mo FM of Charles IV

Group B (Ten Rays)

PEI Bahamas dollarPEI Bahamas dollar reversePEI Bahamas dollar detail
“Bahamas Dollar”, an 8r 1799 Mo FM of Charles IV

Group C (Ten Rays)

PEI Commerce dollarPEI Commerce dollar reversePEI Commerce dollar detail
“Commerce Dollar”, an 8r 1776 Mo FM of Charles III

These were made by the same apparatus – a hard punch in a drop hammer press – as Group B.

Group D (Ten Rays)

These are distinguished by a broken ray among the ten that makes up the radiant sun in the countermark. 

PEI Abbott dollarPEI Abbott dollar reversePEI Abbott dollar detail
“Abbott Dollar”, an 8r 1795 Mo FM of Charles IV

KM 2.1 Prince Edward IslandKM 2.1 Prince Edward Island reverse
KM-2.1 Holey Dollar (5 Shillings), ND (1813), on an 8r 1805 Mo TH of Charles IV (Stack’s Bowers NYINC auction, 13 January 2023, lot 21354)

Group E (Ten Rays)

PEI Wickham dollarPEI Wickham dollar reversePEI Wickham dollar detail
“Wickham Dollar”, an 8r 1803 Mo FT of Charles IV

Described as a countermark cog-wheel the “Wickham Dollar” appears to be a cast 8 reales. Possibly all this group are contemporary merchant counterfeits.

Group F (Nine Rays) 

KM 2 Prince Edward IslandjpgKM 2 Prince Edward Island.reverse
KM-2 Holey Dollar (5 Shillings), ND (1813), on an *r 1783 Mo FF of Charles III (Stack’s Bowers NYINC auction, 18 January 2020, lot 21014)

The other groups are:

Group G (Irregular Countermarks)

PEI Hill dollarPEI Hill dollar reversePEI Hill dollar detail
“Hill Dollar”, an 8r 1808 Mo TH of Charles IV

Only seven rays of the countermark have struck up, and two of those weakly so.

PEI Barrett 1 dollarPEI Barrett 1 dollar reversePEI Barrett 1 dollar detail
“Barrett 1 Dollar”, an 8r 1803 Mo FT of Charles IV

This dollar is unusual for its circle of ten lines in the form of small squares and/or rectangles. “All in all, the characteristics of this coin might lead one to speculate about its legitimacy”.

PEI Haiti dollarPEI Haiti dollar reversePEI Haiti dollar detail
“Haiti Dollar”, an 8r 1801 Mo FT of Charles IV

PEI Mexico 2 dollarPEI Mexico 2 dollar reversePEI Mexico 2 dollar detail
“Mexico 2 Dollar”, an 8r 1808 Mo TH of Ferdinand VII

Group H (Unclassified Holey Dollars and Dumps)

PEI New York dollarPEI New York dollar reversePEI New York dollar detail
“New York Dollar”, an 8r 1813 Do RM of Ferdinand VII

Group J (Unidentified Holey Dollars and Dumps)

Group K (Holey Dollars and Dumps without countermarks)

PEI Unholy dollarPEI Unholy dollar reverse
“Unholy Dollar”, an 8r 1804 Mo TH of Charles IV

This piece has been holed with a tool something like a cold chisel. Faulkner regarded it as a contemporary counterfeit rather than a recent forgery.

Group L (Replica Holey Dollars and Dumps)

Group N

PEI Leroux dollarPEI Leroux dollar reverse
“Leroux Dollar”, an 8r

Group M (Forgeries)