Translate / Traducir

Countermarked coins

Until about 1732, pieces of eight coined in the New World were cobs, which failed to circulate as such in the markets of Europe, but as the European populations in the New World multiplied and commerce increased, the Spanish-American dollar became the predominant trading coin of the Americas.

The rough cob pieces of eight also followed the trade routes from Acapulco and Veracruz to Manila from where they established a supremacy throughout the Pacific and the trading centre of the Far East that was never successfully challenged. With the mechanisation of the Spanish American mints which permitted the striking of a sturdy well formed coinage of sound intrinsic value the Spanish dollar attained a wider circulation than probably any other coin in history. A listing of counterstamped and overstamped Mexican pieces of eight and pesos gives a strong indication of the worldwide acceptance enjoyed by this prestigious coin. This alone testifies it was preferred throughout the West Indies and North Central and South America; in the Far East particularly in China, Indonesia, Thailand, Java and the Philippines; in many of the coastal areas of Africa bordering the Indian Ocean, and in Portugal, Madeira, the Azores, Great Britain, Ireland and Scotland.
A great deal of imagination was expended in devising ways to transform these coins into local necessity money. Mexican dollars were marked for local use by the cutting of crenelated, round, square, heart-shaped or octagonal centre holes, and/or by stamping with a mark of arms, regal portrait, star, crowned monogram, initials, fleur-de-lis, liberty cap and sword, values in Arabic or Roman numerals, mountains and sun, rampant lion, pineapple and other expressive symbols. But no matter how the transmission was affected the reason for so doing was in most instances to relieve a coin shortage by devising a stratagem to prevent the necessity money from leaving the area it was intended to serve.

Other reasons, usually but not invariably economic in nature, also motivated counter stamping of Spanish dollars by local initiative. The pineapple stamp appearing on pieces of eight, and its fractional parts, at the end of the 18th century with a private mark put on circulating foreign coins by a plantation owner to identify them as coins used on Barbados. During the middle of the 19th century, the crowned initials of Frederick VII, king of Denmark, were stamped on foreign coins, including pieces of eight, purchased on the open market and brought to the Danish West Indies to alleviate an extreme shortage of all coins. On 27 November 1884 the officials of Puerto Rico authorised the counterstamping with fleur-de-lis of perforated silver coins to prevent future entries of such coins into the island and to validate those within the country until such time as measures could be initiated to withdraw them from circulations. Officials of St. Croix counterstamped pieces of eight with the mark “StC” andemployed them as a necessity coinage between 1798 and 1813 when Great Britain, trying to win control of the entire West Indies with her navy, prevented the various homelands from delivering coinage to their holdings in the West Indies.

The chop mark struck on pieces of eight by Oriental merchants served a private purpose and was devoid of national significance. The mark indicated simply that the merchant identified by the chop mark had tested the coin and found its weight and fineness to be as represented.

When face and intrinsic values were ideally synonymous, a nation's coinage inevitably reflected the changing patterns of economic reality, as Great Britain's use of counterstamped and overstamped Mexican dollars during the second half of the reign of George III admirably illustrates. War with France, Spain and Holland cut Great Britain off from the plentiful supply of Spanish-American dollars then circulating in Europe, bringing about a severe silver famine which increased the price of silver to the point where the intrinsic value of newly minted coins exceeded their face value. Minting of silver virtually ceased.

When silver returned at the end of hostilities, it was in the form of Mexican dollars. Their price, however, was too high to permit them to be recoined at the British standard so in lieu of anything better they were allowed to circulate as they were.